Baked with love, shared with joy.

From our family kitchen to your special moments — handcrafted sweets that taste like home.

About Sugarplum Sisters

Sugarplum Sisters Bakery is run by two sisters who share a lifelong love for baking. Inspired by their parents—who cultivated both a love for the kitchen and a heart for sharing with others—they began baking as a way to bless people through the gifts God has given them.

Their specialties include chocolate chip cookies, iced sugar cookies, pies, cakes, and muffins, each made with care, laughter, and a generous dose of joy. What began as baking for family and friends has grown organically through word of mouth, with every treat serving as a small act of celebration and kindness.

Baked with love

“For us, baking isn’t just about cookies and cakes — it’s about honoring God through creativity and care, and spreading a little sweetness wherever we can.”
— the Sugarplum Sisters

Our Favorite Creations

Famous Kitchen sink cookies ($15/dozen)

Chocolate chip cookies ($12/dozen)

Buckeye’s ($12/bucket)

Iced Sugar cookies ($15/dozen)

Apple pie ($25)
Cherry pie ($20)
Pecan pie ($20)
Pumpkin pie ($20)

Yellow, Chocolate or Lemon cupcakes ($18/dozen)
Peanut butter cupcakes ($20/dozen)

Custom Wedding Cakes
Contact for pricing!

Chocolate covered strawberries ($20/dozen)

Chocolate covered pretzels ($10/dozen)

How to Reserve your Fresh Bakes

Browse the menu

Explore our daily selection of breads, pastries, cookies, and cakes.

Place your order

Fill out our order form or give us a quick call to reserve your favourites.

Take Home & Enjoy

Pick up your fresh bakes or schedule a delivery!

FAQs

You can place an order by filling out our contact form on the website. Just let us know your favourite pastries, cookies, cakes, or breads, along with your preferred collection time. We’ll get back to you to confirm your order.

We will follow up with you after receiving your order. From there we will arrange pickup or shipping.

Yes! We love creating custom cakes for weddings, birthdays, celebrations, or special occasions. Please contact us directly or add a note to your order with your design ideas.

We recommend placing orders at least 48 hours in advance for breads, pastries, and cookies. For custom cakes, please allow 5–10 days to ensure we can bring your design to life.